Authors
  • David W Kissane1,
  • David M Clarke1,
  • Annette Street1
Organisation
  • La Trobe University1
Year

2000

Excerpt

Existential despair, spiritual torpor, pointlessness, mopishness or acedia – a variety of states have been recognised throughout the centuries to describe a non-caring attitude to life that might easily be confused with depression (1-5).  Such state of deep emotional pain or spiritual distress could be conceptualised as disorders of meaning or hope, but the simple construct of demoralisation can be particularly useful in the palliative care setting to categorise this distress, so commonly ignored within the medical model.  The demoralisation syndrome is thus proposed as a worthwhile diagnosis not infrequently encountered in the terminally ill, one with definable features and available therapies – yet a clinical state that may pass unrecognised or be dismissed as comprehensible and rational given the individual’s circumstances of decline.

Typically the demoralised patient will be heard to state, “I can’t see the point any more; there’s no reason to go on (6).  Such a person may desire death, but not with the acceptance of a life replete with satisfaction and fulfillment, as commonly seen in the elderly who patiently await their death.  Rather with impatience, because of the subtle distress that lies not far beneath the surface, this life is perceived as meaningless and better ended.  Suicidal thoughts develop in the demoralised person who feels trapped and can see no other way out.  Yet such patients may not be depressed, and thus may be perceived by clinicians to rationally choose suicide as a merciful conclusion to their life.

In keeping with nosological principles, we define demoralisation syndrome as a mental state in which hopelessness, helplessness, meaninglessness and existential distress form the core phenomena.  Hopelessness and helplessness arise from an experience of feeling trapped or not knowing what to do, often occurring in the context of alienation and social isolation.  Existential distress within this syndrome is that despair and angst associated with a loss of purpose and meaning to life, including relationships and, in some profound way, a loss of any sense of who one is.  Sometimes intense anxiety can lead to desperation to obtain relief, such anguish signalling an imminent risk of suicide.  The cognitive state of the demoralised is negatively oriented, dominated by pessimism and includes all-or-nothing thinking, in which the world is seen in black or white terms, exaggeration, generalisation and negative self-labelling that lowers self-esteem. The affective state may be lowered, but the person is still able to react with their environment, albeit without enthusiasm.  The conative state lacks motivation or ambition and involves passivity, there being no perception of a worthwhile future.

The psychiatrist might well argue that a diagnosis of Adjustment Disorder should be made for those whom we have described as demoralised – indeed, this could be a technically correct DSM-IV diagnosis (8)- but in the dying, physicians demure from such a poorly understood label.  Some would suggest that there is no place for the stigma that psychiatry brings when the medical prognosis is so poor.  Others perceive the notion of a ‘non-caring’ attitude to life as rational, and the spiritual or existential domains the private concern of the patient.  Commonly clinicians will understand their patient is demoralised, but be heard to comment, “Wouldn’t you be, if you were in this predicament!”  Thus the demoralised person can struggle on without assistance.  Recognition of a formal diagnostic category for demoralisation syndrome would do much to redress this situation.  Turning, then, to the literature on demoralisation, we will further explore its potential for syndromal validity.

The literature on demoralisation – is its face and descriptive validity clear?

Looking first at hopelessness, Engel (9), one of the doyens of psychosomatic medicine, recognised a condition among the medically ill that he called the “giving up – given up complex”.  This was a state of discouragement, of feeling unable to cope and was characterised by hopelessness and helplessness.  In the psychosomatic paradigm, Schmale (10) emphasised ‘giving-up’ as a common pathway leading to physical illness.  This appears to be acute demoralisation.  Around the same time, Gruenberg (11) coined the name “social breakdown syndrome” to describe chronic demoralisation in patients with prolonged mental disorder and this became a focus of attention in the phenomenon known as ‘institutionalisation’.  A considerable psychiatric literature also developed around Seligman’s concept of learned helplessness (12-13), which was applied to an understanding of the development of depression.

Meanwhile, Frank (14-15) described a restoration of morale as the critical aspect underpinning successful psychotherapy.  He conceptualised demoralisation as a persistent failure to cope with stress, associated with feelings of impotence, isolation and despair.  Self-esteem might be damaged, meaning and significance of life lost, and alienation arise when the expectations of others cannot be met.  Undoubtedly influenced by Frankl’s appreciation of the critical sense of meaning in life (16), Frank emphasised the central importance of mobilising hope to induce healing.  Loss of hope and meaning was a certain cause of distress.

A colleague of Frank’s de Figueiredo (18-19), argued that the central feature of demoralisation is a sense of incompetence, developed from uncertainty about any appropriate future direction.  This he contrasted with depression, where a possible direction may be understood, but motivation and drive to proceed is lacking.  Notions such as mastery, locus of control, self-efficacy and learned helplessness intersect with subjective incompetence.  Importantly, a person’s sentiments or assumptions about their ambient world, what Jaspers (20) called the Umwelt, depends fundamentally upon their self-esteem and social bonds.  Disturbance of the personal umwelt may precipitate demoralisation, arising as distress about this sense of subjective incompetence.

In summary then, demoralisation, characterised by a sense of incompetence, can be contrasted with depression, where the latter’s core feature is ‘anhedonia’, a loss of pleasure or interest in life’s activities (21).  This differentiation of demoralisation from depression was confirmed through exploratory latent trait analysis of a comprehensive symptom list from a large Australian cohort of medically-ill patients (22).  Patients hospitalised with serious medical illnesses, including cancer, were interviewed and data collected on a range of physical and psychological symptoms.  Analysis showed that anhedonic depression, demoralisation and grief were completely separate dimensions.  This provided strong empirical data for the separation of demoralisation from depression.

Further differentiation of demoralisation from depression emphasises the future, recognising that the demoralised person can enjoy consummatory pleasure (i.e. in the present), the disturbance being confined to anticipatory pleasure, while the depressed person loses both anticipatory and consummatory pleasure (23).  This distinction can be especially helpful clinically and highlights the essential presence of hopelessness rather than happiness to the descriptive validity of the demoralisation syndrome.

This brief historical review indicates that several writers have been able to recognise and describe this state, which we term the demoralisation syndrome, providing general agreement about its clinical features or face validity.  We suggest that its core or essential features are hopelessness, existential distress with loss of purpose and meaning, pessimism, helplessness and some degree of isolation (i.e. its descriptive validity).  The hopelessness involves loss of generalised [trait] and particularised  [state] hope (28).  Losses of interest or pleasure are not key determinants and differentiate it from depressive disorders.

Demoralisation in the disabled and medically ill – clinical associations

Disfigurement, with altered body image, and physical disability are commonly associated with features of the demoralisation syndrome.  Fear about loss of dignity may develop in addition.  An important US epidemiological study explored the relationship between disability and desire for death and found that the degree to which dependency intruded into personal life predicted the degree of demoralisation (31).  The likelihood of the disabled person expressing a desire to die increased proportionally with the invasiveness of this dependency.  Demoralisation was measured using items of the Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D).  Adjusting for age, sex and education, there was a significant effect on demoralisation by level of disability.  Women revealed greater demoralisation than men, which the authors ascribed to their greater need for a socially meaningful role within that cultural setting.  Similarly in carers, a meta-analysis of studies examining the morale of parents caring for disabled children concluded that demoralisation occurred at twice the rate of that found in the general community (32).

In addition to the disabled, the elderly are a further group in whom demoralisation has been studied.  Gurland and Toner (33) noted that rates of demoralisation in the elderly appeared to be at least double the rate of depression.  Declining physical health with concomitant increasing disability such as deafness was associated with loss of meaning and diminished hope (34).  Resilience could be derived from a sense of personal integrity – described by Erikson as the final developmental phase of life (35).  Acceptance of the life lived and the move from a more self-centered view to a transcendent interest in humankind assisted in letting go of a fear of death.  Those people isolated, lacking social support, and left without a sense of being valued appeared a greater risk of losing meaning and becoming demoralised.  Dependency engendered through admission to a nursing home presented a further hurdle.  Indeed, not only the residents but also their spouses and children carried greater levels of demoralisation in the context of their caregiving role related to a nursing home admission (36).

In studies of the terminally ill, Chochinov and colleagues (37) explored rates of depression and showed that hopelessness contributed uniquely to suicidal ideation when the level of depression was controlled for (37).  This finding is consistent with a series of studies of suicidal patients since Beck and colleagues (38) first demonstrated in 1975 that hopelessness was more highly correlated with the wish to die than was the severity of depression.  Owen et al in Australia (39-40) confirmed this association between hopelessness and suicidality in cancer patients, while Breitbart et al (41) showed the same for HIV-infected patients.  Chochinov went further to display the fluctuations that occur in the desire for death across the terminal phase of illness (42).  This is an important observation in the context of discussion about euthanasia and the meaning of a person'’ desire to hasten death in the midst of an illness experience.

As was seen during legislation in both the Northern Territory of Australia (43) and Oregon, USA (44), a focus exclusively on depression will miss a group of patients who suffer a loss of hope – what we would now understand as a demoralisation syndrome.  Examination of patients seeking euthanasia during the period of legalisation in the Northern Territory revealed that the pointlessness of further life was a prime reason given publicly by those seeking death (6).  Thus, in a television interview entitled ‘The road to nowhere’, one individual expressed his demoralised state as he journeyed to Darwin stating, “There’s no point any more, I’ve seen my time.  I’m ready for the sweet needle” (45).  In others, ambivalence about life and death was portrayed in wavering decisions over months.  Social isolation was prominent in three, while depression went unrecognised in four of the seven patients described (6).  Was demoralisation, albeit unthought about in the terms we are proposing, widespread among those who sought euthanasia?

There are thus a number of associations with demoralisation, including old age (33-34), bodily disfigurement (6, 46), disability (31-32), dependency on others (31, 33-34_ concern about being a burden (6, 46), perception or fear of loss of dignity (47), social isolation (48-50) and desire for death or active suicidality (37-42).

The construct validity of demoralisation syndrome

Here it is important to understand the development of the demoralisation syndrome, paying particular heed to biopsychosocial causes.  Clearly these are multifactorial.  Predisposing factors may lie in the past – the social environment of early childhood and family life may be substantial in developing personal competence, sense of worth, confidence and optimism, leading to resilience that is protective during adversity.  Familial or genetic influences will also play a role here.  Then as the life cycle unfolds, cumulative loss and tragedy will take its toll.  Physical illness with consequent disability, treatment hardship, financial strain, change of role – in short, myriad stressors – may contribute to the story of any individual.

In the precipitation of the current demoralisation syndrome, tracking personal hopes and meaning that the patient has carried through their life and into their illness will lead to an understanding of any change in their view of their future.  Sometimes this will have occurred through their understanding of their prognosis or the limits of available treatment; communication breakdown is common here.

In other circumstances, there may be perpetuating factors that prolong demoralisation.  These may lie in relationships with family members, friends, but also clinical staff, the multidisciplinary team, hospital or institution.  Thus, condemnation of dysfunctional families is suggested as one important factor in keeping morale low, leading to persistent loss of hope (65).  Hopelessness reverberates throughout some families of demoralised, terminally ill patients (56).

Predictive validity of demoralisation syndrome – its course and treatment outcome

T
he course of an unchecked demoralisation syndrome is the development of a desire for death, for the individual feels trapped and helpless with no alternatives and no hope.  For those with advanced disease, this might end in the pursuit of physician-assisted suicide, or their direct suicide (51).  Major depression may, or may not, be an accompaniment of such outcome.  For the adolescent disillusioned and alienated from society, suicide can be a tragic outcome.  Whatever the circumstances, the demoralised person moves toward a perception that continued life is not worthwhile.  For some, this conclusion is reached on a background of a negative and pessimistic disposition, which they have carried across many unhappy years.

The alternative involves an approach derived from a fundamentally different view of the worth of life.  Rather than permitting a continued perception that a patient is beyond care or beyond help, confident reassurance can be offered together with control of symptoms causing distress.  Eric Cassell reminds us that “There is never a time when nothing can be done” (52).  The treatment team needs to go about the delivery of care in a manner that reinforces regard for the person and hope in a life well lived.  Care continues for the sick until the moment of their death, and for their families beyond.

Regardless of the therapeutic model chosen, certain strategies are required to ameliorate demoralisation.  These must work to restore hope (53) and explore meaning – the meaning of life, death, and relationship (54).  Cancer patients have reported a range of unmet needs in spiritual and existential care (55).  Clinicians need to respond to these, promoting an openness to new experience with an optimistic philosophy of life (generalised hope) and a specific focus on realistic possibilities (particularised hope).  Dufault and Martocchio suggested that generalised hope provides the climate to develop particular hopes and rescues a person at times when specific hope seems no longer realistic (28).  Support of grief and uncertainty can also empower a return of hope and meaning.  Moreover, relationships that counter alienation and isolation are fundamental to sustaining this support.

An oft-experienced clinical challenge is in achieving the desired balance between supporting grief and sustaining hope in the terminally ill.  This is the art of good clinical practice.  While grief needs to be empathically acknowledged, excessive anticipatory grieving spoils continued living.  Patients need guidance in striking this balance (56).

Alongside the general model of supportive psychotherapy, cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) offers a specific approach to counter negative thought patterns and promote socialisation.  Attitudes of pessimism and thinking errors such as magnification or exaggeration of reality, a negative focus on specific aspects of the future, labelling oneself as a failure or emotional reasoning provide opportunities to use cognitive techniques to reframe the hopes of the demoralised (57).  Rather than a rigid emphasis on the rationality of thought, an appraisal of how realistic attitudes or beliefs are is sufficient in the palliative setting.  Often such realism leads to an emphasis on ‘being’ rather than ‘doing’ (58).  Regard for the dignity of the person is based on a knowledge of their past and their contribution and worth through the years, leading to a sense of celebration for accomplishments in life (59-61).  Acceptance of their illness requires an acknowledgment of their dependence, but a challenge to any suggestion of them being a burden, reframing this as an opportunity for growth for involved family members.  Exploration of the tasks that remain can assist them to live out their life with continued purpose and meaning (56).  Recognition of their past priorities proves useful to sustain the direction of their contributions, including ongoing conversations with family members, affirming their worth and expressing gratitude for times shared.  With such an approach, the negative thoughts of the demoralised can be reframed to eliminate distortions in their self and worldview, promoting ongoing hope in their continuity of personhood.

Many people who are demoralised will be alienated or isolated from others.  Scheduling of activities and goal setting, the behavioural arm of CBT, assists here.  Furthermore, community based palliative care can help through the support of volunteers and other professionals who come into the home of the sick (62).  Dedicated practical support conveys a powerful message of worth so vital in restoring the morale of the demoralised.

In summary, there are successful therapies to treat demoralisation, in the process alleviating distress and restoring hope and meaning.  These add to the predictive validity of such a syndrome.

Conclusion

We propose adoption of a new diagnostic category, demoralisation syndrome, for its utility to palliative care in relieving distress and psychosocial morbidity in patients, families, staff and the community.  Its conceptualisation categorically as a syndrome will enhance recognition and empower treatment of a not uncommon clinical state.  Studies are called for to empirically validate our proposal, delineate further associated features, and confirm our proposed therapeutic approach.  In the process, we hope this will enrich clinical practice and increase the quality of life of our patients.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This work has been supported by the Bethlehem Griffiths Research Foundation.

A longer version of this paper, with bibliography, will be published in the Journal of Palliative Care.  Readers interested in the references are encouraged to look there.