- Anne Turley1
- Melbourne Citymission1
1999
ExcerptWhen I was a little girl my brothers and sister and I liked to play with a kaleidoscope that someone had given us. Putting your eye up to the viewing end of the kaleidoscope and turning the other end you could see patterns and colours emerge before your eyes. We discovered that often we saw different things in the same pattern or picture. For instance, I'd see a shape of a star my brother would see a series of boxes. Our views and perceptions were different.
I was reminded of our childhood learning as I prepared this paper, for there are very many ways of viewing the mainstreaming of palliative care and the introduction of compulsory competitive tendering. One of the benefits of a conference such as this is that it gives us an opportunity to observe and see these issues from other people's points of view and experience. My views and the comments I make in this paper are one set among many. I offer them as part of a picture and as a contribution to dialogue and discussion. I want to make it clear from the outset that my comments are about systems not people, although later in my paper I do talk about Cecily Saunders and her visionary leadership.
How We See Mainstreaming of Palliative Care and Compulsory Competitive Tendering is Influenced by the Ditch We Live In...
Humberto Maturana, Professor of Human Biology and Cognition at the University of Chile says: "that how we see our world, how we frame and how we respond to the world around us depends on the ditch we live in" (Maturana, 1987).
So let me tell you something about the ditch that helps frame my responses to main streaming of palliative care and compulsory competitive tendering.
A View from Within an Organisation
For the past 15 years I have worked for Melbourne Citymission. Established in 1854 Melbourne Citymission is a major provider of health and welfare services. Inspired by Jesus Christ, we seek to be a community of transformation and social change by:
- Working at the frontier of human need.
- Identifying with people who are marginalised disadvantaged or at risk.
- Working in partnership with govemment and community organisations.
- Exerdsing proper stewardship in the use of limited resources
….of Mainstreaming
In conjunction with the Kellogg Foundation of America and the Federal Government, Melbourne Citymission set up the first modern hospice palliative care service in Australia in 1979. The service was established as a three-year demonstration project and evaluated by the Department of Community Medicine at Melbourne University. It had always been our hope that hospice palliative care would eventually be accepted as part of mainstream health service delivery in this country, however we recognised that the process of mainstreaming would have to be done carefully to ensure that the core of palliative care, i.e. - client centred wholistic care facilitated through a multidisciplinary team was not lost in the transition.
….of Compulsory Competitive Tendering and Mainstreaming
Currently Melbourne Citymission employs 650 staff and operates 42 programs over the whole spectrum of health and welfare. These include services for the homeless, employment and training initiatives, youth, children and family services, disability services, aged care services and palliative care. In the past few years nearly all of these services, with the exception of our nursing homes, retirement centre and hostels have been subjected to compulsory competitive tendering.
My view of mainstreaming of palliative care and compulsory competitive tendering and the Government’s reform agenda is strongly influenced by my commitment to Melbourne City mission's work, its values and our experiences as a not for profit organisation.
A View of Mainstreaming Palliative Care Afforded through Committee Membership …
A further factor in shaping my views on the subject of mainstreaming has been my membership of both the Ministerial Taskforce on Palliative Care and the Ministerial Implementation Committee. Through these committees I have had the opportunity to move beyond the view and confines of Melbourne Citymission's Hospice Service to explore, see and hear something of the Victoria wide picture with regard to palliative care.
What became apparent as I worked alongside others on these groups was that there were large areas of Victoria where people did not have access to palliative care. Allocation of funding appeared to have been frequently driven by historical relationships or political expediency rather than equitable allocation. Overall there was a lack of accountability required by Government and provided by the field for the use of limited resources. I and others became convinced that significant changes needed to be made in the way services operated and were funded if all Victorians were to have access to high quality palliative care.
The Taskforce document outlining a vision for palliative care and the Implementation Committee document on service integration provided a plan for the mainstreaming of palliative care, a concept that many of us accepted as inevitable and if undertaken appropriately, desirable. However the convergence of this trend with the introduction of compulsory competitive tendering has added to the complexity of mainstreaming and I believe has put the process of mainstreaming palliative care in some jeopardy. Only time will tell if this has been so.
The decision to tender our Palliative Care Services was not a decision made by either the Taskforce or the Implementation Committee, nor was it made in consultation with the community sector.
A View from Government…. Compulsory Competitive Tendering as a Means of Procuring Human Services
The decision to tender our palliative care services was made against a backdrop of calls to reduce the size and role of Government, reduce social service expenditure and introduce tax reform. It appears to have been driven by a commitment to Hilmer's National Competition Policy Frames, and the Government's signing, along with other states and territories of the Competition Principles Agreement in 1995. (ACOSS, 1997).
The decision is I believe a wrong one for the following reasons:
My Own Views on Compulsory Competitive Tendering
Introducing Compulsory Competitive Tendering as a Means of Procuring Human Services is Against the Evidence Based Practice Wisdom of Other Countries.
It puzzles me why in a climate where the new catch phrase is ‘evidence based practice’ both the state and federal governments have by introducing CCT into Australia chosen to ignore the evidence based practice wisdom of other countries (Kettnar & Martin, 1994, Smyth, 1997). Experience and research evidence from the United States, the United Kingdom and New Zealand raise serious questions about the use of compulsory competitive tendering as a means of procuring human services. There is no clear evidence to suggest that compulsory competitive tendering improves access or achieves better outcomes for clients or cost efficiencies. In fact the Senate enquiry in response to the Hilmer Report recommended that compulsory competitive tendering not be used in the human service area. Applying economic rationalist principles to the management of human services has the potential, I believe, to erode community life and the well being of all people who make up our community.
Joseph Campbell, well known philosopher and commentator on life, said in medievol days when you entered the city your eyes were drawn to the cathedral, now it is the towers of commerce. Business principles, market forces and an obsession with the bottom line $ amount has become the new world religion (Bennis,1995).
The Purchaser Provider Split Fundamentally Changes the Role of Government Within the Community.
The Industry Commission, speaks of: The charitable sector underscoring many basic values in Australian democracy. It exemplifies, it says, the principles of pluralism, free choice and the right of citizens to participate in and take responsibility for their community. It helps ensure that no government has a monopoly on the way the society deals with its citizens especially those who are most vulnerable because of economic or personal need.
Premised on fragmentation not wholism, the purchaser provider split involved in compulsory competitive tendering fundamentally changes the role of government within the community and the opportunities for creative partnership between government and the community.
This was pointed out recently by Maureen Lyster, a past Minister for Health in this state, currently Executive Director of Aged Care Australia. She said on ABC radio recently that compulsory competitive tendering breaks the notion of the social contract that has operated in Australia for decades, that is the partnership between Government and the not for profit sector…. a relationship that has been highly interactive and built on the notion of co-responsibility. It saw government and the community sector cooperate and collaborate with each other in some very productive, creative and necessary partnerships.… together building a stronger community (Smyth, 1997), who has researched the effect of compulsory competitive tendering on services in the United Kingdom, says that Government has primary responsibility for defining, encouraging and maintaining the public good. Decisions about how the public sector can be managed better should be considered within a clear understanding of the responsibilities of the state.
She suggests that the purchaser provider split fractures the notions of collaboration and co-responsibility. I quote her directly "Compulsory competitive tendering implies greater control by Government." It removes government from direct involvement in service provision, at worst it leads to a bureaucracy that becomes isolated from the community it seeks to service. It reduces the opportunities to work together to develop best practice and undermines a culture of shared values that build cohesive community life.
The either/or notion of compulsory competitive tendering, i.e. either you are a purchaser or you are a provider, fractures and fragments, whereas the both/and notion of partnership and collaboration builds, unites and makes things whole.
Compulsory Competitive Tendering Potentially Undermines the Notions of Pluralism, Free Choice and the Right of Citizens to Take Responsibility for their Community.
It Can Compromise the Autonomy and Independence of Community Organisations
A further concern centres around the fact that unless they have independent sources of funding the community sector is dependent on government for a large section of their funding. With the tight service specification requirements of compulsory competitive tendering the opportunity for creative development of innovative new models for service delivery is compromised. Further, there is a danger that the independence that autonomy of community agencies will become distorted, with community organisations becoming little more than an arm of government. Quality of services is likely to suffer if competition is based on price as agencies promise to do more in order to win contracts. A further complication is the so-called 'creaming' phenomena where agencies place an emphasis on admitting clients with minimal resource requirements for short stays. This makes them look good in relation to their unit costs and throughput and supposedly sets them up well for the next tender. Clients with complex needs are disadvantaged when agencies adopt this approach.
The High Cost of Tendering
The financial, emotional and resource intensive nature of compulsory competitive means that the cost of tendering is high both from the side of the purchaser as well as the provider. If you think about its costs in Palliative Care and multiply those costs across the whole sector of health and welfare one has to ask whether the benefits outweigh the costs. It is hard to imagine any way that they could. There are the costs associated with deploying people to prepare tender specifications, and assess tenders when they are submitted, costs in preparing and writing tenders, redeploying staff and employing agency staff to maintain services whilst other staff are sidelined meeting all the tender specification requirements and getting the tender in on time.
Costs related to supervision and support of staff as they become increasingly anxious about the future. Cost in terms of the brain drain as experienced and highly skilled staff seek more stable employment or choose not to be redeployed to other services when tenders are lost.
Costs to the field as services no longer share information which might be considered to provide competitive advantage to other organisations, costs associated with the loss of collaborative partnerships with Govemment departments on the grounds that their involvement might compromise the purchaser provider relationship. These are further examples of how the either/or thinking associated with CCT fractures and fragments. Fortunately the concept of collaborative advantage rather than competitive advantage is gaining favour -let's hope this trend will continue. For collaboration unites people and builds community. (Smyth, 1997).
Our Society is not Homogenous and One Size Does not fit All.
Our community is not homogenous. It is extremely diverse in culture, language, faith and ethnicity. The needs of the people we seek to provide services for are equally diverse and cannot be met by what I call 'a one size fits all' paradigm of service delivery. As services close with each round of tendering monopolies will emerge. This coupled with a commitment in both the Y AFS and PHACS reviews to bundling and integration of services to form 'mega' services is of great concern.
In Summary my Concerns About CCT Centre on the Following...
- It has been introduced in spite of substantial evidence based research to indicate that there are major problems in following this route.
- It is about market forces and managing dollars primarily, not about people.
- It fundamentally changes the role of Government
- It fractures the relationship between Government and the Not for Profit Sector, and compromises the possibilities for collaborative partnerships with government and amongst service providers.
- It potentially undermines the notions of pluralism, free choice, and the right of citizens to participate and take responsibility for their communities. (spoken about in the industry commission report). It could compromise the autonomy, independence of community organisations.
- It can lead to a bureaucracy isolated from the community it serves.
- It promotes a one size fits all formula to address complex and diverse community needs.
- Monopolies could evolve that become little more than arms of Government.
- Its hard to see how the advantages of tendering outweigh the high costs of tendering.
I have shared my views on Compulsory Competitive Tendering with you, but where does that leave us. The reality of the current environment is that Palliative Care's path to main streaming has converged with the Govemment's reform agenda. We are and will continue to be in what Peter Vaill describes as permanent white water. (Noer, 1996). This reality is for some depressing and overwhelming. However we all have choices about how we will respond to the environment we live in.
I want to move now to a view/vision for the present and the future.
A View for the Present and the Future
I gave this paper a title "How seeing and hearing define our responses to changing times in Palliative Care".
When I was young, I remember a friend of our family, who I now regard as a wise person who used to tell my brothers and sister and I to listen to our hearts. To live by our own inner lights, or to march to the beat of our own drum.
As people in organisations involved in Palliative Care, moving to the future, we need to decided whose drum beat we will listen to and march to. We need to recapture and refocus our energies on what we and the pioneers of Palliative Care have done so well over the years, that is, being visionary leaders. Stephen Covey in his book Principle Centred Leadership says 'the main thing is keeping the main thing the main thing.' We need to stay focused on the principles we want to live by and the outcomes we want to achieve. Covey talks about the principles of fairness, service, equity, justice, integrity, trust and honesty as being true North principles. These principles, he suggests, are like North on a compass we can use them to navigate the 'whitewater' experiences of our lives, our organisalions, and the terrain we are travelling through.
Warren Bennis (1995) in his book 'Becoming a Leader" says, 'if we don't want to be prisoners of the context our first step in mastering the context is to declare our independence and deploy ourselves in a different way. He draws a distinction between Managers and Leaders. Suggesting that Leaders are those who master the context rather than surrender to it.
This table [list, below] further illustrates the distinctions Bennis makes.
A Manager
- Administers Maintains
- Builds systems & structures
- Controls
- Accepts Status Quo
- Always has their eye on the bottom line
A Leader
- Innovates
- Develops
- Builds people
- Inspires
- Challenges
- Has their eye on the Horizon
Obviously we need both Management and Leadership - however Bennis suggests that in business today we have over emphasised the role of management to the detriment of leadership.
We Need a Guiding Vision. A Clear Idea of What We Want to do and the Strength to Persist Even in the Face of Setbacks. Unless We Know Where you are Going and Why, you Cannot Get There. Intention, Purpose and Vision are Critical. (Bennis 1995).
In spite of compulsory competitive tendering the palliative care fields intention, purpose and vision are still the same: That high quality client centred palliative care, facilitated through a multidisciplinary team be accessible to people regardless of their age, diagnosis, ethnicity, sexual preference or social or religious background.
We need to remember that the notion of palliative care and the establishment of palliative care services was not initially an initiative of Government, it was an initiative of visionary leaders in the community.
Visionary Leadership can Transform the World
For instance, in establishing the modem hospice movement in the mid 1960s Dame Cecily broke free from the prevailing culture, world view or ditch that had shaped care of terminally ill persons. Grounded in the knowledge and experience she had gained as a Deaconess, a Social Worker, a Nurse and a Doctor she worked against the status quo. Her work was risky, her work was passionate, she believed in it, and over time she chartered a new course for work with terminally ill persons. Rather than being shaped by her environment she shaped a new environment She had the capacity to create a compelling vision for care of terminally ill people, she translated it into reality that transformed and continues to transform care of the terminally ill throughout the world.
Ghandi once said 'We need to become the change we want to see in the community."(Bennis,1995) Cecily Saunders embodied Ghandi's challenge, as have many of the palliative care services in Victoria.
Capturing Saunders' vision, working in partnership with each other and with Government they have changed the way terminally ill persons are cared for.
The fact that Palliative Care is now accepted and seen as an appropriate part of mainstream health care is a triumph and accolade for all those who have worked so hard over the years to pioneer this work. Accreditation processes and the palliative care standards document provide useful frames and reference points as Palliative Care joins mainstream health. But for the field to continue to develop leaders are required who are passionate, willing to take the risks associated in dlartering new territory, people who are innovative, able to challenge and inspire, and have a vision to the horizon and beyond.
In order to keep the main thing, the main thing, Intention, Purpose and Visionary Leadership, built on the true North principles such as fairness, service, equity, justice, integrity and trust, that Covey focuses on have never been more critical to the field.