- Margaret O'Connor1
- St. Vincent's Public Hospital1
1999
ExcerptNote: Gold fish (not a goldfish) - one that is rare, valuable and unusual in the sea, but that lives alongside many other more common sorts of fish in the right conditions
In line with the Victorian Department of Human Services policies, in April 1998 the Sisters of Charity Health Service (Melbourne Region) re-located one third of its hospice beds from a stand-alone setting at Kew to the acute hospital setting of St Vincent's. As well, the home care service that had been based at Kew moved to Fitzroy, with the intention of modelling the triangle of care.
The issues for staff in the lead-up to this move revolved around concerns for the loss of a specialty practice, the need to have the work regarded as distinctive and a fear of patient and family's needs being overlooked in the busy-ness of this setting. There was a perceived clash of philosophy with palliative care workers regarding their work as being aimed at seeking the best quality of life, as opposed to the acute hospital's emphasis on treatment and cure for illness and disease. The concern expressed by staff was that, in placing palliative care among mainstream health services, the distinctive characteristics of palliative care would
In this paper I shall argue that the distinctive aspects of palliative care are contextual. Much of what is experienced as different is in fact mostly a result of palliative care being historically separated from other parts of the health care system. Gaining impetus from Government directives, it is timely for palliative care to re-establish its place in mainstream health care, both in the physical location of services as well as the sharing of expertise.
Relevant Historical Perspectives
Until the late 1970s, care of the dying seemed to remain mainly the hidden work of religious orders like the Sisters of Charity and the Little Company of Mary, continuing a tradition of picking up the work that did not appear to fit into the acute system. There was a commitment to keep care of the dying separate from other aspects of health care, most likely in recognition of the different needs and pace of care at the end of life. What is of particular historical significance in the move of Caritas Christi to St Vincent's is that the reason Caritas Christi seems to have been established in 1938 was because the Sisters felt that St Vincent's was not the place for people to die.
This large and special place, then, is being asked to re-create itself. The 70 beds will be divided into smaller groupings across the state, with closer relationships encouraged between the home care services, the hospice beds and the acute services needed by this client group. With this different model, the emphasis on a large bed-base with smaller home care services is reversed. Home becomes the central focus of care and the beds used for care intermittently as needed, with beds being more accessible in smaller, more socially acceptable groupings.
It could be argued perhaps, that a separateness of thinking developed, due to the geographic and philosophic isolation of the hospice, which then grew into a seemingly distinctive practice. While the stand-alone hospices have served a particular historical purpose, over time the isolated setting has seemed to contribute to palliative care practice being relatively unchallenged by the changes happening in the broader health care system.
Juxtaposed with this view of care is the contemporary sense that dying and death are uncomfortable subjects which ought to be hidden, since they are a communal reminder of the inability of humanity to control everything. Caritas Christi has always been that reminder, that very visible place on the hill, where the community stories about the work range from a long-remembered gratitude to those based more on mythology than on fact. In removing this visible sign we need to be careful that we too are not complicity in the hiding away of dying. So care of the dying has become a double-edged sword - a communal denial of the work and an unconscious encouragement of invisibility, but a comfort to know that this communal responsibility is being undertaken by someone.
In both home care and outpatient hospice services, we need to claim the distinctive context of palliative-care - for people at the end of life, and the specific knowledge grows from that context. Thus the challenge facing the staff who have moved into the acute setting is not so much how to hang on to these specifics, as how to disseminate their knowledge and influence practice in the acute sector, while optimising their own learning about relevant attitudes and practices. Rumbold (1998, p.3) supports this new challenge, noting that: "Co-operation has required the hospice movement to shift from emphasising its distinctiveness, as it did in its inaugural period, to focusing on the ground held in common with other services".
Burucoa (1993) also notes that: "a self-centred exclusiveness negates the goals of palliative care. No one is the sole possessor of the truth... .' (p 30). Burucoa urges those with the skills and experience of caring for the dying to offer this to their colleagues.
Challenges for Staff
As expected the settling process for staff at St Vincents over the last 6 months has been one of continual challenge in establishing a palliative care presence in the acute setting.
There has been much discussion in the general hospital about the role of the beds in this setting and it currently is an openended and dynamic conversation. Impacting on the organisational structure in an appropriate manner in order to empower the hospice's place has been quite difficult to achieve. For example, there is ongoing exploration about finding relevant meetings and staff groupings within the hospital structure that will support the continuum of care and begin conversations about the commonalities of practice. The ongoing creative tension is one of needing to be part of the life and culture of the hospital, yet wanting to maintain the distinctiveness of practice. In endeavouring to model the 'triangle of care' of integrated roles across settings of home care and in-patient care, barriers have been encountered - the navigation of unions, the need to experiment with different models of care and to push the bounds of traditional practices. All this work is only just beginning.
As well, there has been a need to re-visit the sorts of patients who use the hospice beds - are they appropriately referred, or are they just being pushed around the system, with Caritas Christi as the final and limitless repository of those that fit nowhere else? The imperative to reduce the length of stay has come at a time when the available beds at any one site have been reduced, so the flexibility to have people stay as long as they wish is no longer there. The Caritas Christi model of the last few years of a small home care service attached to a large hospice bed base has now been reversed. The increase in patient discharges over the last 6 months indicates that those requiring care may not be at the terminal stages of their illness.
Health care system issues in relation to palliative care still need considerable work. Despite the increase in availability of home care services, a good deal of palliative care is still being provided in the acute setting. Calder notes that in Victoria: 'in 1995 about half of all palliative care clients supported in the community died at home, a proportion which rose steadily from the introduction of MIP funding in 1988. About 40% died in hospital with 10% dying in hospice services. A survey undertaken in 1994 found that 4.5 % of all acute hospital bed days were used by in-patients in the palliative phase of treatment or care'. (Department Human Services, Victoria 1996a in Calder 1998 p 64). The Australian Association for Hospice and Palliative Care also noted that, throughout Australia, only about half of those people eligible to receive care from a palliative care service were able to do so. (MHPC 1997).
By placing palliative care services in the acute hospital, there is more ability to promote staff exchanges and educational supports and, potentially, the false boundaries between acute intervention and palliative care are removed. There is an inherent aim of caring for more people in creating these more closely aligned systems. The current systems are unable to provide more care, so the only way that this can be achieved is for services to explore new ways of working with other services in order to meet this need. In particular, the specialist palliative care nurse will be required to provide a leadership role in the teaching and education of staff in different settings, like aged care facilities. This may mean letting go of some of the direct care roles in order to spread this much needed expertise further (O'Connor 1995).
Into the Future
Will this gold fish survive this move into the ocean? I think the answer to this is dependent on several key factors.
Palliative care services need to demonstrate the contribution that they make to the continuum of care for those people facing the end of life. The acute sector, in acknowledging that not everyone is skilled in care of those facing the end of life, must be prepared to accept and use this expertise. There is an unprecedented opportunity to develop formalised service relationships across the range of those disciplines needing to be accessed by terminally ill people and their families. 'The acceptability of a palliative care service in a major hospital will determine its survival... Services are dependent on the full support and commitment of sponsoring institutions and on secure and sufficient funding'. (O'Neill et al 1992 p 412).
Work needs to be undertaken to build on that already commenced to articulate the work of palliative care. Recognising that palliative care is more than quantitative tasks we should, nevertheless, not shy away from developing ways to measure and describe our practice. The development of consistent and comparable data across the state is the only way to monitor the effectiveness of current services and a key to funding further service development.
Education and evidence-based research need to assume a high priority in the demonstration of palliative care practice. The close involvement of recently developed academic units is essential in the support of staff wishing to undertake such research. Formalised relationships between the academic chairs and services will assist such research activities and promote relevant and accessible educational models.
One of the ways described to ensure the future of palliative care is the development of more flexible models of care, perhaps involving a range of service providers to meet needs. These models of care may challenge previous firmly held views about how the best palliative care can be delivered and by whom. Courage is needed to risk new ways of providing care for more people, not timidity in holding on to what has been familiar.
For a number of reasons, there is a need to find ways to further promote inter-disciplinary practice. Concern has been expressed about the increasing medicalisation of palliative care, to the detriment of other disciplines. Continual clarification is needed in order to maintain the balance between providing expert medical care and medicine being the dominant discipline of the team. Similarly, the role of the nurse is one that requires balance, in order to ensure that the nurse makes the best use of his/her expertise and is not necessarily the person who does everything for the person receiving care. Roles and boundaries need constant reflection in promoting holistic care.
Conclusion
While services can proudly look back on many years of the development of individual palliative care services, it is now timely in the current service re-organisation, to address the system issues in order to find a place within mainstream health care. It is appropriate to return to a place in the health care system, but with a strength and expertise that may not have developed had palliative care stayed within the mainstream.
Palliative care services face an urgent task of articulating their practice, particularly in exploring the bounds of what is distinctive and contextually specific and what is common to all good care for the terminally ill in any setting. Above all, we must keep in mind the needs of those requiring palliative care, in developing flexible and creative systems to respond to the challenges that arise in their care.
As services become better known through the mainstreaming process, nurses will need great confidence in their 'portable expertise', which will need to be transferable to wherever it is needed. More and more Burocoa says: "Palliative care is more rediscovery than fresh ideas, more adaptation than creation; therefore the whole sociomedical profession should be concerned with this discipline". (Burucoa 1993 p 32).