Author
  • Roger W Hunt1
Organisation
  • Unknown1
Year

1993

Excerpt

The development of hospice/palliative care has enhanced the values of autonomy and the quality/quantity of life ratio in the management of terminally ill patients. In distancing itself from the voluntary active euthanasia, however, hospice/palliative care rhetoric contains two myths which should be dispelled:

  1. If optimal palliative care is provided then no dying person should experience pain or distress
  2. Hospice care neither prolongs life nor hastens death

Even in the best palliative care units where state-of-the-art treatments are used there is significant suffering. Many symptoms are impossible to control (eg anorexia, fatigue, weight loss) while others can be only partially ameliorated (eg neuropathic pain, terminal confusion, dyspnoea). Many patients also suffer psychologically, emotionally and spiritually despite concerted efforts at various types of counselling.

Palliative interventions can have the effect of either prolonging or shortening life. Good pain control may enhance general well-being, increase morbidity and the desire to live. One the other hand, the doses of medication required to palliate some type of pain and terminal distress can cause sedation, dampened cough reflexes, "pharmacological oblivion", and a hastened demise. This may be regarded as a form of "slow-stream" active euthanasia.

As the hospice/palliative care movement matures, religiously-inspired idealism is giving way to secular, academic objectivity. The limitations of palliative care and the extent of residual suffering are being more systematically assessed and recognised. The movement’s maturation and a broadening of the repetoir of palliative treatments for residual suffering is reducing the distance to voluntary active euthanasia practices.