- Louise Peters1
- La Trobe University1
1993
ExcerptThis study was conducted to determine the perceptions of patients and their nurses of the restraint experience and the characteristics of nurses' decision- making. The application of physical restraints is an issue needing further understanding to ensure only appropriate use. The presence of humanistic shared decision-making in the application of restraints is an important aspect of care also requiring exploration. No work has been undertaken to investigate the use of physical restraint in the hospice setting where restraints are used, and the objectives of care focus on comfort rather than cure. The Hospice Unit of a 100 bed public hospital in Melbourne was the setting chosen for this study with twenty patients and their primary nurses participating. The study consisted of two parts.
Patients and nurses were interviewed using a semi-structured interview guide to determine their perceptions of the restraint experience. A self-administered, semi- structured questionnaire was used which included questions adapted from Strumpf and Evans' (1988) study to determine the reasons for restraining patients, and Donoghues' (1990) adaption of Fenton's (1987) Scale of Humanistic Behaviour to measure nurse caring behaviours in relation to shared decision- making.
Descriptive statistics were employed to analyse the quantitative data. The semi-structured interviews and qualitative data were examined for common themes. Inferential statistics were used to compare group differences. Overall, the findings demonstrated that for 60% of the patients, the application of cotsides was not a negative experience. However, the use of cotsides as a form of restraint needs to be explored as it affected the remaining 40% of patients adversely. The Fisher Exact probability test was applied to compare responses by restrained and non-restrained patients at time of interview, but all comparisons of patients’ response categories were non-significant. The findings also revealed that the nurses value shared decision-making but often face a dilemma when incorporating this in their practice. Their concerns regarding the safety of the restraints is balanced with other safety issues, as the modal reason for the use of restraints was prevention of falls. A t- Test was done to compare group mean scores of nurses who shared the decision to restrain with their patients and those who did not. No significant difference was found between the two groups. The findings highlight the importance of careful assessment of the reason for the patient behaviour causing the decision to restrain.