Author
  • Rodney M Sloman1
Organisation
  • University of Sydney1
Year

1991

Excerpt

The general purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of progressive muscle relaxation and mental imagery, both single and combined, on cancer pain, anxiety, depression, and quality of life in persons with moderate to advanced cancer. These interventions were taught to the patients as a component of their nursing care. The study consisted of two clinical nursing experiments. The first experiment was conducted over the period between January 1988 to May 1989, and the second experiment took place between November 1990 and June 1992.

The first experiment was community based, the experimental setting being the patient's home. Subjects were 54 non-hospitalised persons with cancer pain who were randomly assigned to one of four experimental conditions. These were: (1) progressive muscle relaxation; (2) mental imagery; (3) both progressive muscle relaxation and mental imagery combined, and; (4) control. Each subject participated in the study for three weeks. Pretesting was done with the short-form McGill Pain Questionnaire, the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale, and the Functional Living Index-Cancer Scale. Morphine and non-opiate prn analgesic intake was recorded daily. Four training sessions in the respective relaxation treatment were given and subjects were requested to practice the techniques twice daily and to use them whenever they experienced breakthrough pain or were emotionally upset. Subjects received the same questionnaires as a posttest.

The second experiment was hospital based and involved 67 patients who were admitted to the oncology ward of a large teaching hospital for treatment of cancer. Subjects were randomly assigned to one of three groups: (1) taped relaxation instructions, (2) live nurse-directed relaxation instructions, and (3) no relaxation training. The relaxation technique used was the combined method of progressive muscle relaxation plus mental imagery. As in the first experiment, subjects participated for three weeks and were pre-tested and post-tested with the same questionnaires. Daily records of analgesic intake were recorded. Relaxation training was given twice weekly for the first two weeks and subjects were encouraged to use the technique whenever they felt pain or emotional distress.

The results for both experiments suggested significant improvements in the management of cancer pain, depression, and quality of life. The variables of pain sensation, present pain intensity, overall pain severity, non-opiate prn analgesic intake, and depression were reduced in both experiments. Pain affect was reduced in the first experiment but not the second. Anxiety levels and morphine intake were not significantly reduced in either experiment. Results also showed no significant difference between the taped or live methods of teaching relaxation.

Three conceptual frames of references formed the theoretical basis of the study. They were: (1) the gate-control theory of pain, (2) the relaxation response theory, and (3) the self-care theory of nursing practice. The findings of the study were discussed in terms of these theories.