- Mark Boughey1
- Royal Melbourne Hospital1
1999
ExcerptThe Victorian Government's initiatives for its future funding of community-based palliative care were described in the 1997 document "The Way Forward". Access and equity were to be the cornerstones of the thrust for changes in palliative care provision. In broad terms, the medical aspects of community-based palliative care were given considerable reference and prominence in the document as an integral part of the multidisciplinary team. It was asking tendering agencies to demonstrate medical coordination that would facilitate better access and equity to specific palliative medical services in the community arm of the triangle of care. There was a sense that the changes could, if possible, bring about improvement in the overall provision of medical services, particularly in the rural sector.
The reality of working within the changes in the first half year appears to have brought with it many concerns, disappointments and stresses that have medical staff questioning the reality of what has been achieved and at what cost to themselves and to palliative care.
In preparing for this talk, I spoke with a cross section of community-based palliative care doctors, program managers and clinical nurse consultants, in metropolitan, semi rural and rural locations. I asked them a number of questions as to how the changes had impacted, specifically, on the provision of community medical palliative care. The time frame did not allow the accumulation and processing of hard data. As a consequence, my presentation is a reflection of their thoughts and concerns.
I discovered, through my conversations, that there was a great deal of variation of thoughts expressed amongst the regions. Many of the issues were regionally based with problems carried over and unresolved from the services in place prior to the change over following the outcomes of the tendering process. A number of common themes emerged. These centered around the concerns about the ongoing lack of, and limited availability of, suitably experienced medical staff; the lack of funding for adequate medical staffing when available; the downgrading of the medical role to save on costs; and the expansion of a service area with increased client numbers without any increase in medical hours. Personally, doctors expressed distress at the level of change and the lack of participation in the tendering process. These factors have lead to a sense that, although overall there was better access for patients to the palliative care services in name, access to adequate palliative medical services had not been achieved in practice and that across Victoria equity in the availability of a palliative medical specialist was not really to be found.
The Tendering Process
Although there had been representation of palliative medical specialists at many levels in the ministerial committees and the development and consultative processes of setting up the tendering process, it is surprising, when inquiring, how few palliative care medical officers were involved in the specific discussions and writing of their own agency's or region's tendering documents. Although one could speculate, it is difficult to ascertain the reasons why individual agencies did not encourage the input of their medical personnel or the medical people themselves did not make it their business to be involved in the nitty gritty of their own agency's tendering process. It is interesting that the medical personnel who were most involved in their own agency's tendering process generally appeared to be more satisfied with the outcomes, even though it had brought about change and an increase in work loads. They felt that they had been part of the process and understood the overall picture of the tender, particularly why service provision was changing in terms of budgeting and resources and how this would redefine the medical role. The most distressed doctors had found that they had had little or no input into the tender writing discussions. As with other aspects of managing change, ownership and understanding of the process appears to be important. Many of the doctors felt that the new model they were working under had been imposed upon them not only by the government, but by the tendering agencies.
The documents of "The Way Forward" made reference to the need for improvement in the equitable provision of medical services. However, the brush strokes in the document were broad and in fact, other than using the tender to demonstrate the medical coordination across the triangle of care, there was little in specific recommendations as to medical hours, ratios of patients to medical hours and so forth. This was left to individual tendering agencies to decide upon and demonstrate in their documents. The specific details of how an agency would provide specialist palliative medical care was drawn from an agency's understanding of the medical role, and the importance it placed on this in its overall concept of palliative care. This brings into view the importance of the understanding, or lack of understanding, of tender writers as to the nature of palliative medicine and the difference it presents to practising medicine which is unique and special to palliative medicine, rather than general practice or other hospital-based specialisations. Was this an oversight or was it a result of developing ways of saving and shifting costs? One agency put it bluntly that when dollars are short, why pay a doctor's high rates when a phone consultation to the hospital can be used instead? In retrospect there was a feeling that there had been assumptions made about the general practitioner's capacity to fulfil this role with only a little coaching from nursing staff and a failure to appreciate the 'hands on' nature of medical work in providing palliative medical care in the community. This was a thought echoed by many of the doctors I interviewed. Although telephone conversations and advice are important for the provision of good palliative medical care there is, at times, a need for 'hands on' home visits to assist the nurses and the general practitioners.
Assumptions had also been made about maintaining previous levels of medical input and that, with expansion of services, there would be a concurrent increase in medical services. Again, not being part of the process meant that it became an area of increasing stress when it was realised that the doctors would be then doing the same, if not more, work with no compensatory increases in availability. In the rural sector, how could services that had no access to palliative care specialists create a document that had provision for medical hours when no specialists were available? To many it seemed like a 'Catch 22' situation. Although formal links were written about with regard to a region's relationship with a specialist medical person, some of the tenders still have no money available to provide any real medical consultancy other than telephone connections. It has been hoped that, in some of the regional centres, general practitioners with enhanced skills could take on this role. However, the reality is that this would be confined to an hour or so a week and with no expectations of home assessments.
If one is looking at what can be learnt, I believe that medical personnel must engage, and be part of, tender writing and discussion when the next round occurs. This is crucial to maintain and retain a medical presence that reflects the nature of good palliative medical practice.
The Triangle of Care
In keeping the focus on community-based palliative care, most practitioners have had a mixture of positive and negative thoughts about the provision of palliative care around the triangle of care since the tendering process. The positive comments related to the overall provision of palliative care within the triangle and that overall access to palliative care had improved. The way in which clients, hospitals and general practitioners accessed the providers had become more structured and streamlined and movement processes better known. Therefore, access to beds in the hospital and hospice sector had become generally more streamlined although there were still shortages of beds.
Negative thoughts related to the specifics of the provision of medical care. While access to services was occurring more readily, this did not mean that the patients were able to access all aspects of the team readily, particularly the medical components. Prior to the change over after the successful tendering, some doctors had been involved in seeing a great deal of the new referrals. They were able to plan preventative home assessments, as well as to plan more than a one-off visit with possible follow up visits at the home of more medically unstable patients. To some, the increased volume of work has meant that much of this aspect of their work has been lost and that a shift has occurred from preventative visiting to emergency patching up or triaging. To many, this is a great stress. Rather than a problem that may have been sorted out at home in the past, the doctor is not able to physically visit them at home and if the general practitioner remains unsure and uncertain, the nurses may have no alternative but to send the patient back to hospital. There was a great sense that the medical arm of palliative care was leading to a greater failure in the community arm of the triangle of care and that more difficult problems with symptoms were having to be sorted out in hospital. Although the utilisation of palliative care nurse consultants is important, there are times when a medical assessment is needed and required by the treating local doctor. No matter how good the nursing relationship with the doctor is, the general practitioner needs guidance from another medical officer. Even though much can be done over the telephone, 'hands on' assessment with the problems will always be important in the assessment, diagnosis and treating process. If the palliative care physician is not able to respond to these requests then it is likely that the patient will end up back in the hospital system, even if that is not their wish.
Although it is still early in the tenders' three-year cycle, many medical officers felt that loss had occurred in the provision of the community arm of medical palliative care. There was a nervousness that this was likely to deteriorate further. For regions that had no 'hands on' medical input, the possibility of establishing it in the future seemed to be an improbability.
The Medical Role
I have already touched upon aspects of the medical role of doctors working in palliative care which encompasses many of the aspects of medical care that seem lacking in hospital and general practice. In embracing the overall philosophy of palliative care, the attraction of palliative care and the reason why most moved into this field was not only to be able to provide specific medical care surrounding the palliative stage in patients' lives. It was also to have time to spend with patients, to be able to see people in their home settings and to be able to have time for good communication and discussions with patients and their carers.
Many now feel their role has been downgraded since the tendering process. Several spoke of being palliative care doctors in name but no longer in practice. As I have mentioned, irrespective of their speciality, a doctor in clinical practice is defined by the actual work they do. This is also a consideration to recognition as a specialist by their college authority. The loss of time to provide patient assessment and follow up has lead to a great deal of grief and stress amongst the palliative medical practitioners. Some are Questioning whether they really have an ongoing role in community-based palliative care, others are considering restricting themselves to hospital practice. Downgrading can be seen in many ways. A shift from 'hands on' visiting to increasing telephone liaison. The elevation of the nurse consultant into a predominantly advisory role, which the medical officer may have had, is perceived as an administrative shift in costs. In comparing some of the city services, there was great variation when looking at crude approximations of medical sessions per number of agency client ratios. For approximately 100 clients at anyone time, one service provides three sessions a week for clinical work while others provide only one to two sessions for a comparable number of patients.
For some practitioners the success in the tenders has meant that the area that they cover has expanded without any compensatory increase in sessions. Not only has the volume of work increased, but the time taken to travel from different parts of the regions has become a difficulty. Some doctors cover an entire region while the nurses and other team members have been split to cover only a part of a region. The changes have also meant that it has become increasingly difficult to be available for involvement in other activities away from clinical work such as teaching students and staff or being involved in team developmental processes. Although provision for regional consultancy has been made to cover some of these non-clinical aspects, this type of consultancy has not yet been defined by many of the services.
Another aspect of the work that is stressing some of the doctors is the inequity in pay that some experience when compared with others in the field. Many services will pay the rates equivalent to a hospital-based specialist. Although this may seem a considerable expenditure to some services, failure of some agencies under the Locktenberg Agreement to honour a uniform rate of pay is a distressing reality. General practitioners are able to earn better rates of pay, which again undervalues the specialist role palliative care doctors play. There are specific agreements to pay specialists and attracting people to community agencies will become harder if equity is not maintained.
The Personal Effects
Many of the palliative care doctors have been involved in a time of change. The process of tendering had been a time of stress, but since the changes have occurred, stress seems to be the word on everyone's lips. Concern about the future and worry about chronic understaffing is a predominant cry. Even if the number of doctors trained in palliative care is increasing, there is no provision to utilise them. Again, the people who had been involved in the tendering and those who seem to have had least change felt least stressed. To some extent we are all defined by the work we do and the working environment. The perception of a downgrading and the undervaluing of the medical role, particular1y when, in general, medical practitioners feel they give so much of themselves to their work, has had a distressing effect on many. Many of the doctors have both hospital and community-based appointments and there is certainly a growing dissatisfaction with the community arm. Comments about 'giving away' palliative medicine or moving to purely hospital practice were certainly made on several occasions.
Conclusion
This dissertation has canvassed the opinions and thoughts of palliative medical workers, nurses and managers. Although it is only 6 months into the first year, in general terms medical practitioners believe that the tendering process has brought about better working relationships and better access to palliative care. However, there is considerable regional variation about the way in which agencies have interpreted and implemented the specifics of the tenders awarded. This in turn reflects the nature and make up of the medical component of the agencies the doctors are working for. The Specific effects on the medical arm of service provision has brought with it a lot of dissatisfaction amongst the palliative care doctors. The core of their worries appears to be the undervaluing of their role and expertise. It is also the failure of the implementation of the tendering process and government plans to bring real access and equity to the medical aspects of palliative care. Access is better overall, but when looking at the specifics, access to medical input which was poor before the tenders remains poor, even diminished. In country areas in particular, the lack of medical input may also be a reflection of broader difficulties of attracting medical people to the remote rural sector.
In looking ahead to the next tendering round, what can we learn? A more active input into the discussions and writing of tenders seems to be crucial. Being part of the process of change appears to make it easier to deal with. Speaking out about the value and uniqueness of what a palliative medical specialist can bring to a team needs to be emphasised and publicised. The medical specialists need to put their hands up and be counted. It seems to be a case of hands up or the hands won't be there any more.