- Coral-Lee Keep1
- Monash University1
1994
ExcerptThe question "Is it ever morally permissible to withhold or withdraw artificial hydration and nutrition in Palliative Care?" arose due the ambiguity of the section dealing with palliative care, under the Medical Treatment Act 1988.
In this thesis, I have attempted to address the question and in doing so, to justify my answer, yes it is morally permissible to withhold or withdraw artificial hydration and nutrition in palliative care when (1) an autonomous patient refuses artificial hydration and nutrition, (2) an agent refuses artificial hydration and nutrition on behalf of a previously competent patient, when it is known that the patients would not want life-supporting medical treatments in the given circumstances, (3) an incompetent patient’s views are not known, but on appeal to the ethical principle of beneficence the withholding or withdrawing of artificial hydration and nutrition is justified, and (4) when the provision of artificial hydration and nutrition is futile.
In an endeavour to justify my answer, I have addressed the broad areas of palliative care, the Medical Treatment Act 1998, the ethical principles of respect for autonomy and beneficence, and in greater depth the area of artificial hydration and nutrition. I have attempted to address the issues involved in each area as the issues impinge on the other areas and therefore the answer to the proposed question.