- Michael Eburn1
- Unknown1
1998
ExcerptEuthanasia and medical end-of-life decisions have been the subject of public debate following the passage, and subsequent invalidation, of the Rights of the Terminally Ill Act 1995 (NT). This thesis considers the ethics and Australian law relating to euthanasia, the withdrawal and withholding of life sustaining treatment, and the provision of medication that may, as a side effect, hasten the death of the person receiving the treatment. This thesis explores the ethical arguments used to distinguish euthanasia from other medical end-of-life decisions and concludes that the distinction is neither legally nor ethically satisfactory. It is argued that in cases where it is known that the death of the patient will follow from a decision to withdraw, withhold or administer particular treatment, then there is no significant moral difference between that action and euthanasia.
The law in this area is then discussed and analysed to show how medical-end-of-life decisions are currently regulated in Australia and in some overseas jurisdictions. From this analysis it is argued that there are good reasons to reform the law in Australia to allow ‘voluntary euthanasia’, and in some cases, ‘non-voluntary euthanasia’, to be considered as part of the normal medical practice to be regulated in the same way as other medical end-of-life decisions. In particular, it is argued that out of all the suggestions for law reform, the model suggested by the House of Lords Select Committee on Medical Ethics, namely that these matters should be left largely in the hands of the medical profession with the opportunity for independent review if required, is the most appropriate.