Authors
  • Sanchia Aranda1,
  • Sanchia Aranda1
Organisation
  • University of Melbourne1
Year

1999

Excerpt

Palliative care has evolved from what has affectionately been referred to as the modern hospice movement. Hospice care, largely arising from the charismatic leadership of several extraordinary people, such as Cicely Saunders. Hospice encapsulates a philosophy of care that was a reaction against inhumane treatment of those dying in a health system consumed by its capacity to avert death and cure disease. Several characteristics of early hospice services point to the necessity to reconsider the appropriateness of clinging tightly to these origins.

First, early hospice pioneers shared an aim to care better for people who were dying. However, the knowledge base for doing so was small and largely articulated as a 'style of care' rather than demonstrated and reproducible interventions. While not arguing against the importance of the process of care as well as the outcomes, little evidence existed, or indeed now exists, that hospice services improve outcomes despite the beliefs of experienced practitioners. Services have largely relied on the testimonials of vulnerable and grateful families to demonstrate their worth to the overall health care of Australians.

Secondly, early hospice services were established as demonstration projects, separate from and often antagonistic to mainstream health care. While the vision of Cecily Saunders was to model a new way of caring for the dying that could eventually be brought back into the practices of health services, this has been slow to occur. Indeed, hospice services have been criticised as providing deluxe dying to a minority of those who require such services (Johnston & Abraham, 1995).

Thirdly, hospice service development has been largely Western in focus and closely linked to religion. The plurality of the Australian population demands provision of services in ways that seek to avoid exclusion, real or perceived, on the basis of race, class and religious observance. Diagnosis, age and closeness to death are also points of potential exclusion from access.

A Useful Metaphor – The Mainstream and The Anabranch

As we pause for thought during this conference, about the origins, current status and future of palliative care, I would like to offer a metaphor to help us understand the changing times in which we live. This metaphor extends the idea that palliative care has developed external to the mainstream. Indeed, this metaphor of the ‘Anabranch’ continues the watery theme of this conference. An anabranch is a branch stream leaving a river and re-entering it lower down (Australian Oxford Dictionary). For example, the Edward river, which runs through parts of Southern NSW, is an anabranch of the Murray River. When sitting on the banks of the Edward to all intents and purposes you appear to be sitting on the banks of the mainstream. The Murray is nowhere in sight and can be largely ignored as irrelevant to the life and ecology of the Edward.

If this metaphor is applied to palliative care some useful observations can be made. From the perspective of the anabranch, in this case palliative care providers, they provide a unique, quality service that meets the needs of the target population. The services are provided to the ill person and family, acknowledge dying as a part of life, focus on the provision of symptom relief and comfort and extend to bereavement support of the family after the patient's death.

Extending the metaphor further, there is little need along the anabranch to consider the mainstream, other than as a source of input of raw materials - water and fish for the anabranch and patients for the palliative care service. The danger inherent in this perspective arises both for the anabranch and for the palliative care service. Reductions in water supply from the Murray can leave aspects of the Edward running dry -billabongs or backwaters, separate from and irrelevant to the mainstream, occur as a result. For palliative care remaining out of touch with the mainstream signals a danger of being out of touch with changes in health care delivery, the needs of the whole community and, importantly, isolated from health funding and support. It also leaves palliative care unable to influence the development of services in the mainstream - if our message is so important and fundamental to the wellbeing of those who are dying and their families then this influence must extend across the health system.

Why should palliative care opt to be part of the mainstream rather than exist as a beautiful, demonstration project in the backwater of health?

Being Mainstreamed – a Changed Perspective

Being mainstreamed forces palliative care practitioners and service managers to develop new and useful perspectives on palliative care. However, like the return of the anabranch to the mainstream, this is a time of turbulence and change. The waters of the anabranch and the mainstream mix and are each irrevocably changed as a result. Our first challenge is to consider and then influence the shape of palliative care in this future.

The advantages of being mainstreamed are many. Of greatest importance is the security of funding that comes with recognition of palliative care as an integral part of the health system. While many may argue that funding is insufficient, the reality is that Victorian palliative care and indeed palliative care throughout Australia is fortunate in the extent of Government funding received. Globally Government sources account for only 50% of all palliative care funding, ranging from less than 7% in Africa to almost 63% in Australasia (Wilson & Kastenbaum, 1997). Other countries envy the degree to which Government supports our palliative care efforts.

The World Health Organisation (1986,1990,1996) has consistently argued that the key measure ensuring availability of palliative care to those who need it is Government recognition and inclusion of palliative care in health policy directions. This has been achieved in Australia and demonstrates Government commitment to palliative care.

The perceived down side of access to Government funding and integration into mainstream health policy is increased bureaucratic control (James & Field, 1992). Bureaucratic control results in increased pressure to demonstrate that service provision is effective, efficient and available to all. The work that has been undertaken in Victoria as a result of the directions set for palliative care essentially focuses on these three goals. These goals are not as out of step with the early visions of palliative care pioneers as you might at first believe. For the remainder of this paper I would like to focus on these three challenges, or as I believe opportunities, to take palliative care to the next stage of its development – access, quality/effectiveness and efficiency.

Issues of Access

Access to palliative care is a global issue. In developing countries social class and the ability to purchase services largely determine access. In Australia geographical distribution of services and diagnosis are the major determinants of access. If you live in a large city and have cancer access is virtually assured. However, even having cancer is no guarantee of access. Work by Palliative Care Australia found that of those who die from cancer in this country, only 56% receive palliative care. This figure is possibly inflated given that some people would have counted twice or possibly three times in this survey if they received care from home, hospital consultancy service and inpatient hospice. It can certainly be argued that many people may not want to receive palliative care services but these figures still demonstrate the issues of access needing to be addressed. These issues are expanded if you also take account of non-cancer related palliative care needs, the needs of non-English speaking and indigenous Australians, the needs of children and the needs of those in isolated and rural communities.

Little is known about the extent of palliative care need in the non-cancer population. Work in the United Kingdom has established a reasonable consensus that the largest diagnosis groups that would benefit from palliative care are stroke, cardiac and respiratory disorders, multiple sclerosis and rheumatoid arthritis. In this study this equated to 11 non-cancer patients per general practitioner per year and would mean more bed days per year than currently provided in that region for cancer related palliative care (George & Sykes. 1997). These groups are clearly disadvantaged in terms of access to palliative care. Principles of justice demand that the needs of these groups, living with debilitating diseases amenable to palliative interventions, be addressed.

Issues of access are a key motivation of Government palliative care policy. However, these needs are clearly beyond the capacity of current palliative care resources and demonstrate the inherent limitations of a specialist model of service provision, a point I will return to later. The danger of current mainstreaming is that we have limited capacity to a) assess non-cancer palliative care need & b) to determine the extent to which palliative care services should be integrated into existing generalist services or be offered as integrated specialist services. As the anabranch re-enters the mainstream palliative care providers are forced to face this inequity of service provision and must carefully consider the best use of palliative care resources. Questions of 'who benefits most from specialist palliative care?', 'how do they benefit?', and 'how effective is integration of specialist and generalist services?' arise. These questions link access issues to those of quality and effectiveness.

Quality and Effectiveness in Service Provision

Demands of mainstreaming include being able to demonstrate to funding sources and consumers the benefits of receiving palliative care. The challenge in this demand is to move beyond the glowing testimonials of patients and families describing 'angels without wings' to producing evidence of the effects of palliative care on outcomes. I believe there are opportunities in this challenge to more dearly understand our own practice and to derive a great sense of achievement in ensuring those in our care benefit from our involvement. Do we actually achieve the sacred cows of palliative care philosophy – symptom control, patient and family-centred care, holistic care and interdisciplinary teamwork? Let us take the easiest of these – symptom control.

How many palliative care services in Victoria can clearly articulate the profile of symptoms experienced by patients receiving their services both on entry to the service and over time? What percentage had pain? How many patients had pain scores on admission over 5 on a visual analogue scale? More importantly, what percentage of patients with pain scores over 5 achieved a reduction in pain within one week of admission that was sustained over time? These questions are fundamental to questions of quality in our services. The challenge to demonstrate the effects of what we do to Government and consumers is the opportunity to demonstrate this to ourselves.

The Victorian Government is currently funding the development of a quality assurance instrument for community palliative care that is being trialed in three palliative care services in 1999. We have recently been able to feed back the pilot data on 53 patients to these services and the potential for this information to set service directions was clear.

All 53 patients had at least one physical symptom scored as greater than 5 on a 10 point verbal scale. 40 of the 53 patients had at least one symptom above 8. 15 patients achieved a decrease in all symptoms over the time of the pilot but 31 patients had at least one symptom that remained unstable or high over time. A symptom was considered problematic if the score remained 5 or over. Problematic symptoms were fatigue (22 patients), pain (10 patients), bowels (8 patients), breathing (8 patients), nausea (7 patients) and sleep (9 patients). Of the non-physical symptoms, anxiety was of greatest concern, being problematic for 17 of the 53 patients.

The pilot was the first time the participating services had been able to consider this information about their client group. While the information was not representative of their patient profile, it pointed to problematic areas in quality of care. Is it acceptable to have more than 80% of patients where a problematic physical symptom remains high throughout their admission? What strategies can be implemented to reduce this number? More specifically, if more than 30% of patients have problematic anxiety, what staff development needs to be undertaken to help staff be more effective in the management of anxiety?

This study has also raised awareness within the participating services to a number of issues including:

  • Variability in staff assessment of patients.

  • Nurse discomfort about formal assessment of psychological and social issues.

  • Limitations of documentation.

  • Mechanisms for intra- and inter-team communication.

It is important to acknowledge that not all quality and effectiveness issues in palliative care can be reduced to numbers. Consumer perceptions of our services and stories demonstrating the qualitative dimension of palliative care remain important but need to be carefully assessed. If we argue that the process of giving care is as important as outcomes we need to be able to demonstrate how this is so. There is a current prevalence of patient and family satisfaction measurement that may only seek to confirm what a good job we do rather than seek to identify gaps or problems in service delivery amenable to change. In addition, such tools are often limited to completion by those who read and write English and may miss important service development imperatives. Measurement and assessment of quality and effectiveness of palliative care must do more than confirm our belief in ourselves. It must seek to make us uncomfortable, shake our sacred cows and spur us on to improving the care of those receiving our care.

Efficiency – The Down Side of a Specialist System

Bringing palliative care into the mainstream aims, at least in part, to ensure an efficient service system. Efficiency is about avoidance of waste, elimination of gaps and duplication and the integration of various aspects of the health system. However, in these times of economic restraint it is also about doing more with fewer dollars. Governments see mainstreaming as a means of achieving the expanding health agenda without a necessarily similar expansion of health spending.

It is clear from what I have already said that the palliative needs of the Australian community are beyond the scope of current resource allocation to palliative care. Demands for greater funding will necessarily fall on deaf ears and cannot be the sole source of action. Our challenge in having to confront this reality is to consider how the specialist palliative care system will work with and alongside other health care services to provide palliative care. We are finally being brought face to face with the long established tension between palliative care philosophy and the development of palliative care as a specialisation.

Despite the emergence of palliative care as a specialist field of medical, nursing and allied health practice, palliative care is largely argued to be a general approach to care of the dying able to be practiced in any setting and by all health care practitioners. Palliative care is thus noted for its ‘low tech, high touch’ approach (Twycross, 1995); a view that undermines and minimises the skills and knowledge that enable practitioners to provide expert 'high touch' care to those who are dying. A generalist view of palliative care is visible in Campbell's (1990) claim that a hospice ethic would involve practitioners in a commitment to become redundant as a more universally available social system of care for the dying becomes a reality. While most palliative care practitioners would embrace Campbell's view, their status as specialist practitioners provides an interesting tension that militates against determined action to achieve such redundancy.

Whether or not this is practically achievable or even desirable, the question of redundancy creates a demand to demonstrate the value of specialist input. If palliative care is to remain in charge of its future and the palliative care of our community, some difficult questions about specialist service impact need to be addressed.

Firstly, if palliative care philosophy is a style of care able to be delivered in any setting, what systems of care support this? The assumption that an integration of palliative care with other health goals is possible lies at the heart of the mainstreaming agenda for palliative care. We must investigate this assumption. Can non-palliative practitioners be supported to implement aspects of palliative care into their practice? What is the role of specialist services in provision of this support? Is it possible to work with palliative care and curative care simultaneously? Can Campbell's vision become a reality or are the tensions too great?

Secondly, if a specialist service system is important, what mechanisms can be put in place to ensure that those who can most benefit from specialist palliative care have access to that care? To whom should inpatient palliative care be offered? Is inpatient palliative care largely about acute symptom management, short-term respite and the last few days of terminal care? One of the unsavoury realities of inpatient palliative care at this time is that we are seen as a soft admission option. Does the elderly person who is dying but largely asymptomatic achieve better outcomes in an inpatient hospice than in a nursing home?

Conclusion

Some would argue that the philosophy and principles of the modem hospice movement have been irreparably damaged by the discursive shift to palliative care (Biswas, 1993). Palliative care offers an alternative, slightly distanced from religion and the reality of death. Mainstreaming of palliative care offers an even greater challenge to the hospice movement. This challenge lies in ensuring palliative care ideals and values remain central to the delivery of care to those with progressive and terminal illness. The need to retain these ideals and values as central to the delivery of care creates an imperative to clearly articulate what we do and its benefit to the ill person, their family and to society at large. This imperative is currently lagging behind service delivery developments. If palliative care is irreparably damaged by mainstreaming the blame lies not only with Government. We must accept responsibility for allowing the hospice dream to become ideologically stagnant rather than a dynamic force continuing to shape the care of those at the end of life. It is not too late. This time of change offers us the opportunity to rethink, to evaluate where we have been and where we must go and to shape1he future. Are you ready to take on the challenges that lie within this opportunity?